| Karminder Singh | Opinion | 2 Oct 2015 | Asia Samachar |
By Karminder Singh Dhillon, PhD (Boston)
The kesri (xanthic) coloured flag that Sikhs respectfully call the Nishan Sahib and seen flying at Gurdwaras is to the Sikh place of worship as Sikh dastaar or turban is to Sikh identity.
A few points on its origin, function and manner of respect may be as useful to the reader as much of some commentary on worship-like rituals that have sprung up in recent times in relation to the Sikh flag.
Sikh scholar-cum-historian Kahn Singh Nabha writes that the Nishan Sahib was originally called Jhanda (flag) Sahib and that it was founded by Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji. Folks who get offended when someone refers to the Sikh flag as “Jhanda” can take note of this fact.
In the village of Fagwara in Punjab, there is a historic Gurdwara marking the transit of the seventh master Guru Har Rai Ji during one of his travels from Kartarpur to Kiratpur, called Gurdwara Jhanda Sahib, lending credence to the fact that the term “Jhanda Sahib” had come into existence then.
THE SIKH REHAT MARYADA AND NISHAN SAHIB
The Akaal Takhat sanctioned Sikh Rehat Maryada (Sikh Code of Conduct) or SRM has the following stipulation relating to the Nishan Sahib in Section 3, Chapter 4, Article V (r):
“Every Gurdwara should install a Nishan Sahib at some high location. The cloth of the flag should either be Basanti (Xanthic) or Surmayee (greyish blue) in colour. At the top of the Nishan there should either be a Bhalla (spearhead) or a Khanda.“ (a double edged straight sword, with convex sides leading to slanting top edges ending in a vertex.
One is hard pressed to find a Gurdwara flying the Nishan in the the Surmayee colour these days, even if it was the standard colour of Nishan Sahibs flying in the Gurdwaras in townships where I grew up.
FUNCTION OF THE NISHAN SAHIB
It is clear from the words “at some high location” in the SRM stipulation above that the primary purpose of the Nishan Sahib was to act as a sign board and a symbol of the Gurdwara.
If one reads Kahan Singh Nabha’s writings of the original functions of the Gurdwara, one can see the logic of the Gurdwara needing a symbol that was visible from afar for Sikhs and especially for non-Sikhs.
Beyond being a primary place for the teaching and practice of Sikh Spirituality, the Gurdwara was to have a number of other functions.
The Gurdwara was meant to serve as a sanctuary for the protection of dignity of women. If such a function sounds odd it is because we Sikhs have terminated this function for so long, that it is no longer part of our collective memory. I doubt our modern Gurdwara parbhandaks are even aware of this primary function of the Gurdwara.
I further doubt that a battered, displaced or otherwise needy woman seeking protection in our modern Gurdwaras would be accommodated in any meaningful way!
The Gurdwara was also meant to serve as a resting place for the weary traveller. Again, if this function sounds strange, it is also because we have stopped accommodating travellers in our Gurdwaras from a long time.
The Gurdwara was further to serve as a “meal-house” for the hungry. The key word is “hungry”. Serving meals to the well fed or those who have better cooked meals waiting in their houses does NOT fall in this category even if this has become the standard practice of langgar in our modern Gurdwaras.
All the above functions were meant equally for the Sikh and non-Sikh. It is on these functional grounds that Section 3, Chapter 4, Article V (k) of the SRM reads:
“No person, no matter which country, religion or cast he/she belongs to, is debarred from entering the Gurdwara…”
This then is the primary function of the Nishan Sahib. It is located high as a beacon of hope for any woman seeking to protect her honour, as a light house for a weary traveller seeking a place to rest, and as a welcome sign for a hungry/displaced/homeless person seeking a meal. The Nishan Sahib is, for all intents and purposes, a sign board that stands tall and calls out for those who need protection, solace and a meal. It is inviting them, in the name of the Guru to come to the Gurdwara and be served.
TALL SIGN BOARDS BUT NON-FUNCTIONAL GURDWARAS
Gurdwaras have perfected the art of building taller and sophisticated Nishan Sahibs – complete with lights, pulleys, and other electronic display systems. Some are visible from tens of miles. Such would be wonderful if the Gurdwara actually provided the appropriate services to those it did attract from afar by it 100 feet tall flag pole.
But if the Gurdwara fails to provide the basic functions as mentioned above, then its tall Nishan Sahib is akin to a defunct hospital that has a huge sign visible from ten miles, but tells patients who show up that there is no doctor, no treatment and no medicine there.
WORSHIPPING THE SIGN BOARD
But Sikhs have by and large, turned the Nishan Sahib into an article of worship. Sikhs are seen walking around the flag pole in parkarma (circumambulation style), folding hands to metha tek or bowing down to the concrete base of the Nishan repeatedly, rubbing their noses on the base, tying pieces of cloth or ribbons to the flag pole and then taking them home a few days later as blessed material, and much more.
Those who consider such practices as respect or reverence ought to think a little deeper.
One does not respect road rules by metha tek or bowing to road signs. One does not display any reverence to a welfare home by circumambulations of its sign board.
One does not acquire health by trying ribbons to the hospital’s sign board and then taking the ribbons home as equivalent to medicines. One does not become educated by doing repeated parkirma of, or by rubbing ones nose repeatedly on the school sign board.
If only everything was this easy! What then makes us think that we can acquire the Guru’s blessings by doing all the above to the Gurdwara services sign board that is the Nishan Sahib but by doing nothing to ensure that the Gurdwara actually functions the way it was supposed to function?
A Sikh ought to consider his or her head as priceless to only bow before the Guru Granth Sahib. Bowing before just about everything within the precincts of the Gurdwara – gate, steps, stairs, mats, photos, base structure of the Nishan Sahib etc – even if they are all part of the Gurdwara’s physical structure – is to suggest that they are all equal in stature to the GSS.
MEANINGLESS PRACTICES RELATING TO THE NISHAN SAHIB
Sikhs are known for their penchant to slide down the slippery slope of rituals. Where we cannot steal from others, we invent our own.
One wonders where the idea of dressing up the flag pole came from. The logic of it is dumbfounding. The Gurdwara I attended regularly did not have such dressing and one illiterate parcharak from India took it upon himself to berate the parbhandaks and the sangat openly for allowing the “Guru’s Nishan” to stand “naked.”
He went on to call the dressing “chola sahib” (literally: holy dress) and said the covering was akin to the “kachera” and that its function was to protect the “dignity” of the Nishan Sahib.
I asked him after his pseudo katha if the Nishan Sahib should also be adorned with the remaining three kakars – kirpan sahib , kra sahib and kanga sahib!”
Gurdwaras are known to change the Nishan Sahib on Gurpurabs. There is no mention in the SRM of such a requirement. Logic dictates that the Nishan Sahib ought to be changed when it is torn or appears faded. No need for any fanfare.
One would have surely witnessed the Nishan Sahib change being done in worship type rituals that can take a couple of hours and is witnessed by entire sangats.
Some Gurdwaras have constructed fulcrum type flag poles which allow the flag pole to be laid horizontal. Hours are then spent washing the pole in pails full of milk or yoghurt or lassee. The entire pole is then towel-dried and dressed up in cloth with tie backs.
Some Gurdwaras use cranes for the same purpose. Other have ladders.
Doing such is munmat, or deviant practise, plain and simple. It is waste of milk, lasee, cloth, time and energy. It is not supported by the maryada or Gurbani and there are no historical records of Sikhs doing this in previous eras.
One can appreciate if the purpose of the Nishan changing ceremony is to educate or inspire love within the sangat for the Nishan Sahib. But the only “education” that takes place is one relating to self-constructed rituals.
Kahn Singh Nabha writes that the two majestic Nishan Sahibs that stand in the doorway of the Darbaar Sahib were first put up as wooden poles in 1775 by the Udasi Babas who ran the place then. They were broken up in a storm in 1841 and one was rebuilt by Maharaja Sher Singh and the other by Desa Singh Majithia. Both the flags are made of iron but adorned with copper plates. The high base was rebuilt in 1923.
Such facts illustrate that the Nishan Sahib can and has taken a variety of forms – wooden poles and flags of iron included. Nowhere however is the practise of covering up the pole with a “chola sahib,” or washing it in milk or kachee lassee shown as a practise except in recent times.
THE SIGN MUST FIT THE FUNCTION
A Nishan Sahib is just that – a Nishan, a symbolic sign board. We can make it tall, big and visible from as far as the eye can see so that it attracts those who are in need of Sikh sewa towards humanity to come to the Gurdwara. But then, it is our duty to ensure that our Gurdwaras are functional to serve such needs. What are we doing about creating truly functional Gurdwaras, is the question.
Having sign boards that are the tallest and most unique but having nothing to offer to those who show up in response to these sign boards is deception – fraud even.
Worshipping and undertaking ritualistic practices involving a sign board is to miss the point all together. Worse, it represents our own spiritual hollowness.
NEXT WEEK: THE ROLE AND FUNCTIONS OF A GURDWARA.
Karminder Singh Dhillon, PhD (Boston) writes on Gurbani and Gurmat issues in The Sikh Bulletin, USA. He also conducts Gurbani Katha in local Gurdwaras. He is currently running a class on understanding Anand Sahib at Gurdwara Sahib Petaling Jaya on Sundays 6.30pm–8.30pm. He is based in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Karminder starts class on Anand Sahib, Ardas (Asia Samachar, 2 Aug 2015)
Artee and Sikhi – KARMINDER (Asia Samachar, 10 Mar 2015)
ASIA SAMACHAR is an online newspaper for Sikhs / Punjabis in Southeast Asia and beyond. Facebook | WhatsApp +6017-335-1399 | Email: firstname.lastname@example.org | Twitter | Instagram | Obituary announcements, click here |
Thank you, Karminder Singh ji for that very enlightening article. I have “fought” against this and other similar issues for a long time but to no avail.
With my limited knowledge I addressed this very problem way back with an article published in 1999 in Understanding Sikhism (the IUS Journal). I approached and addressed the problem purely from logic and “gut feeling”. I wish I had access to your article then. Below is an excerpt from that article relating to the Nishan Sahib issue:
“Ceremonies surrounding the Nishan Sahib: In some of the gurdwaras the Nishan Sahib is washed in milk prior to its raising. What is the logic behind this? The stone/concrete base of the pole of the Nishan Sahib is invariably fenced off. Why? I have been told that “people sit on the base, children play on it, and this constitutes disrespect for the Nishan Sahib.” Really? Isn’t this being petty and carrying things a bit too far? I distinctly remember as a child that the concrete base of the Nishan Sahib in the Police Sikh Gurdwara in Ipoh was deliberately made wide, and of a suitable height, to serve as a place to sit, and sit everyone did. Were Sikhs of that era disrespectful of the Nishan Sahib? In India, at a historical gurdwara in New Delhi, I have actually seen Gursikhs bowing and paying obeisance (matha tekna) to the Nishan Sahib. Is this what respect means? If it is then I want no part of it.”
Once again, thank you.
Sarjeet Singh Sidhu
Although very informative and a wake up call to many, the author in his article above, has, I believe missed out on two very important points. Correct me if am wrong.
Firstly, the Nishaan Sahib although introduced during the time of Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji, was actually a request by the Sikhs of the Guru. The Sikhs of the Guru were the ones who initiated the idea of having a Nishan Sahib, then Chanda Sahib.
Secondly,apart from the reasons above, i.e. “a beacon of hope for any woman seeking to protect her honour, as a light house for a weary traveller seeking a place to rest, and as a welcome sign for a hungry/displaced/homeless person seeking a meal”, Sikhs at that time also wanted a way to make known to others that where there was a Nishan Sahib hoisted, the Guru resides. That way as one enters such a compound, one would have to exercise certain level of discipline and respect.
This article makes perfect sense to me. I have always wondered why r people washing a pole, dressing it up etc? My daughter even sings ‘deh Shiva’ during Vasakhi Day at PJ Gurdwara during d whole process. Yet never dared to ask d question out simply because i consider myself illiterate in sikhi understanding. I have learned so much by attending Dr Jee class. We r so blessed to have him in our community. Guruji bless u Dr Jee!
I congratulate Dr Karminder Singh Dhillon from the bottom of my heart for very informative article on the Nishan Sahib as an Idol for worship by the Sikhs. He has also very briefly mentioned about dis-functioning of the Gurdwaras all over the world.
We, the Sikhs at large and the those who consider themselves as the authority on Sikhi, have gone far away from the basics of philosophy of Guru Nanak – the founder of Sikhi.
This article should serve the purpose of about Rs 7.8 lakh collected for awakening of Sikhi recently in California.
The Sikhs need such highly educated preachers like Dr Dhillon rather than the preachers taught from missionary schools or Gurdwaras who have no knowledge of Science. and logic and depend upon mythical stories to explain Sikhi..
I always get satisfaction whenever I read Dr Dhillon’s papers and about his efforts to preach Sikhi.
Devinder Singh Chahal
I agree with the above as I find it offensive as Sikhs have started to pray to everything else except Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji. In the gurdwara, all will talk and don’t even pay attention to the Kirtan and the paath. They allow their kids to run around in the darbar sahib and scream and talk loudly, concentrate on their handphones when all should be praying. But will bow to staircase, poles, cloth and what have you not.
The writer has, as always, displayed solid research, gurbani centered-ness and gurmat grounding. Above all his use of logic is superb. All qualities are sadly missing in most of our granthis, parcharaks, ragis and preachers in our gurdwaras and institutions. All the latter seem to offer is half baked stories, painful illogic, and skewed interpretations of gurmat and banee. Kudos, Asia Samachar for carrying such refreshing ideas.
Karminder Ji. Your article above is very well researched. I await your next article: The Roles and Functions of a Gurdwara. I am sure you will be writing from your personal observations: what Gurdwaras are doing and the transformation needed to go back to the original role of Gurdwaras.
May the Guru’s blessings be upon you to guide the Sikhs who are being misled by unqualified granthis and story telling kathakaars who mislead Sikhs towards rituals – thus deviating from the actual spiritual journey as per Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
Truly eye opening article. Our Gurdwaras, preaching and overall charge of Sikhi has been hijacked for too long by maryada-deaf and gurmat-blind people. Worse by people with agendas to misguide Sikhs. We appear so gullible. Let’s stop worshiping the Nishan Sahib and work towards ensuring our Gurdwaras provide all the sewa that the Nishan Sahib promises to mankind who come under its protection.
Well written article which was researched well and summarised appropriately. Also highlights the need to educate our sangat of man made rituals that our Guru has rejected.
Very well researched and an eye opener piece. Adequately supported by SRM stipulations, historical background and powerful logic. I eagerly await the writer’s next piece on the Role and Functions of Gurdwaras. I hope his research can tell us how our Gurus wanted Sikhs to run our Gurdwaras and if we are indeed running them as such.