Dasam Granth ‘parkash’ in Kuala Lumpur serious transgression of maryada, says MGC


| Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia29 Dec 2016 Asia Samachar |

PUSHING THE ENVELOPE: A photo grab showing Dasam Granth, once known as Bachitar Natak, brought to Gurdwara Sahib Titiwangsa in Kuala Lumpur accompanied with chaur seva. – PHOTO GRAB FROM SIKHINSIDE VIDEO

Some quarters are seemingly bent on pushing the envelope in promoting the Dasam Granth (DG), a collection of work earlier known as Bachitar Natak (BN) and purportedly written by Guru Gobind Singh, in the Malaysian setting.

In the latest salvo, a local Sikh group brought a copy of the DG into the darbar sahib of a gurdwara in Kuala Lumpur, complete with someone doing the chaur sahib, providing almost the same level of respect usually accorded to the Sri Guru Granth Sahib (SGGS).

The incident on Monday (26 Dec 2016) took place at Gurdwara Sahib Titiwangsa (GST), a gurdwara controlled by a group of Sikh businessmen, during a kirtan darbar programme organised by the SGGS Academy, a Kuala Lumpur based Sikh organisation.

In a latter to local gurdwaras, Malaysian Gurdwaras Council (MGC) noted: “The Sikhinside had telecast live on 26.12.2016, the Parkash of Bachitar Natak (Dasam Granth) in the Darbar of SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI at Gurdwara Sahib Titiwangsa, Kuala Lumpur which is a serious violation of the Panthic Parvanat Sikh Rehat Maryada (SRM).

SEE LETTER: MGC: Parkash of Bachitar Natak (Dasam Granth) in Darbar of SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI in violation of SRM

“The Historical evidence is that Bachitar Natak (now called Dasam Granth) was earlier known by other names. That there was no Bachitar Natak (Dasam Granth) in existence at the time of Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji’s Joti Jot in 1708.

“We do not know whether the Parkash of BN (DG) is on a permanent basis in the Darbar of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji (SGGS Ji) at Gurdwara Sahib Titiwangsa. Even if the Parkash is on a temporary basis, it is still a violation of the SRM as no Parkash of any other “Pustak” can be done in the Darbar of SGGS Ji. The BN (DG) ‘Parkash” could have been done in another room but not in Darbar of SGGS Ji.”

In the letter, a copy of which was made available to the Asia Samachar, MGC said that gurdwaras ‘must take note of the above serious transgression of the SRM’ and that its executive committee (exco) will ‘meet urgently to decide on the next cause of action’.

When contacted on the matter, SGGS Academy leader Paramjit Singh told Asia Samachar: “You may want to put the question to the Sanggat members present for a better view.”

Some Sikhs present at the event confirmed that the chaur sevaa was done over the copy of the DG brought out to the darbar sahib, in the presence of SGGS.

The so-called DG has been a controversial topic in Malaysia for some time now and is seen as having a potential to divide the Sanggat in this and neighbouring countries, as seen from its effects abroad. However, up till now, no gurdwara in Malaysia has ever installed, either permanently or temporarily, the granth.

The debate revolves around the compilation which some Sikhs believe are the compositions of Guru Gobind Singh, while others believe they are not entirely the compositions of the tenth Guru of the Sikhs.

On the local front, MGC has floated the slogan ‘Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada’ to rally Sikh organisations, gurdwaras and individuals towards the SGGS. The slogan is taking root with a number of gurdwaras, including Seremban and Klang, adopting is as part of their leadership ethos.

In the above letter, dated 28 Dec 2016, MGC said: “The Parkash at Titiwangsa Gurdwara of the BN (DG) is a clear violation of the SRM, although the Parkash may be on a temporary basis. The quoted Parampra of Lakhi Jungle is Manmat and is a serious transgression of SRM.”

The letter added that as ‘guidance’, those doing DG reading in Darbar Sahib in gurdwaras abroad have been banned from doing kirtan/katha in the gurdwaras.

“The Gurdwaras were reminded by MGC vide letter dated 05-09-2016 to remain united. At a meeting called by M.G.C. on 7th August 2016 and attended by representatives of MGC, KDM, SNSM, Melaka Vidyala and Sikh Scholar’s a unanimous decision was taken that all Gurdwaras and Sikhs must abide by the SRM which hitherto had bound the Sikhs World wide like a glue.

“Not complying with SRM will bring disaster and disunity among the Sikhs. Just imagine having different Maryada regarding reciting Kirtan, Hukam Lena, Sadharan Path, Akhand Path, Gurbani di Katha, Anand Sanskar etc. if SRM as the uniting force is not followed,” it said the letter.

In an earlier letter dated 15 Nov 2016, MGC had called upon the Akal Takht to take action against parties placing other scriptures at par with the SGGS.

In the strongly-worded letter to the Sikh body based in Amritsar, the Kuala Lumpur based MGC has urged for ‘visible and concrete steps’ to push back attempts to place DG at par with the SGGS.



[ASIA SAMACHAR is an online newspaper for Sikhs in Southeast Asia and surrounding countries. We have a Facebook page, do give it a LIKE. Follow us on Twitter. Visit our website: www.asiasamachar.com]


MGC: Parkash of Bachitar Natak (Dasam Granth) in Darbar of SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI in violation of SRM (Asia Samachar, 29 Dec 2016)

Statement from Gurdwara Sahib Selayang Baru  (Asia Samachar, 19 Dec 2016)

Selayang incident: I’m appalled with the lies (Asia Samachar, 18 Dec 2016)

Attempted assault on Dr Karminder Singh after talk at Selayang gurdwara (Asia Samachar, 17 Dec 2016)

Driven towards fundamentalism (Asia Samachar, 16 Dec 2016)

‘Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada’ comes to Rawang (Asia Samachar, 15 Dec 2016)

Dr Anurag’s claims on Ek Granth defective to the core, says Dr Karminder (Asia Samachar, 11 Dec 2016)

Kuala Pilah Sikhs lend an ear to ‘Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada’ concept (Asia Samachar, 4 Dec 2016)

Perlis Sikhs do sehaj paath for Ek Panth, Ek Granth, Ek Maryada (Asia Samachar, 30 Nov 016)

Global Sikh body backs Malaysia, US councils (Asia Samachar, 29 Nov 016)

American Sikh Council endorses the “One Granth and One Panth” (Asia Samachar, 28 Nov 2016)

Seremban leadership endorses ‘Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada’ (Asia Samachar, 27 Nov 2016)

Klang gurdwara makes history with launch of ‘Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada’ (Asia Samachar, 24 Nov 016)

Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada: A logo that says it all (Asia Samachar, 3 Nov 016)

All is not well at Akal Takht (Asia Samachar, 20 Oct 2016)

Guru Nanak was an original, says Women In Sikhi conference organiser (Asia Samachar, 16 Oct 2016)

Lord Singh of Wimbledon on Dasam Granth  (Asia Samachar, 10 Oct 2016)

SGGS-DG Discourse: Another stumbling block towards Ekta of the Sikh panth? (Asia Samachar, 4 Aug 2016)

‘One Granth One Panth’ call from Global Sikh Council (Asia Samachar, 11 April 2016)

Foreign maids voted at Ipoh gurdwara AGM, MGC ‘regrets’ police presence (Asia Samachar, 3 March 2016)

Ipoh gurdwara AGM: Another volunteer held, lorry driver vows to ‘get back their membership’ (Asia Samachar, 2 March 2016)

Ipoh gurdwara president defends actions, says no more response from him (Asia Samachar, 1 March 2016)

Police show up at Ipoh gurdwara AGM (Asia Samachar, 28 Feb 2016)

 JAGIR: MGC managing granthi entry, tandardising maryada at gurdwaras  (Asia Samachar, 19 Nov 2015)



  1. Kulant sian…Guru maniyo granth is not originally from bachiter natak the correct name…It comes from rehatnama of bhai chaupa singh… and wss added in 1895..Into bachitter natak to try and fool sikhs….Looks like you too have one eye that works,obe hear thst can hear partially…And partially psralysed brain. …Wld you like to explain and tgriw light …From the sides that do work in you . Ty

  2. There is seriously a transgression of the maryada.Kulwant, ji for your esteemed information, the saying Agiya Bhai akal ki comes from the rehatnamas of Bhai Chaupa Singh rehatnama.

    It was added into the Banchiter natak, in 1895, when a man corrected the GURU’s bani, in the sodhak committee report, a copy of which I have in my possession.

    The reasons given for inclusion of other Hindu mythology, is given as that ” so Sikhs will not go to other avenues to learn about Vedic literature.

    may, I point out very simply, if you are not aware, the booklet amrit vela has been adulterated by devious agents, and unfortunately this has bot been caught on until now.

    Can you also explain how and why two formulations of uniformed Sikhs maryada in 1913 and the second in 1925, did not include the discussion of this BN?

    If you are still naïve, the definition of the word gurduara, apart from all the legislative acts, has been reiterated by supreme Court of India, in 2009, that a Gurduara only has a Guru Granth sahib, NOTHING else.

    I can assure,you, the mischief makers are not bound to win,should this go to courts anywhere.

    They may have blown a little hot air from patna, but the reaction of the majority of the community is arising, not in favour of the traducers and Guru nindaks of Gurus Granth and One panth.

  3. There is no problem with bringing Dasam Granth inot Guru Granths Sahibs hazoori and doing katha of it. We have Dasam Bani and Aad Bani side by side in gutke.

    Bhullar Sahib, coud you shed some light on “Guru Maneyo Granth” i.e. who said it, and where is it written? Thanks

  4. It has been bothering me, since the shouting in the Darbar Sahib in Selayang Gurdwara recently and the throwing of a brick at the Parchaar’s car, as to why the Academy people are all riled up with the Logo “Ek Granth, Ek Panth, Ek Maryada” when I believe that this is a wonderful rallying point for all Sikhs.

    However, the actions of the Academy, by installing the Bachittar Natak (BN) in Titiwangsa Gurdwara in the presence of Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji , has answered my question.

    Their objection to ‘Ek Granth” is to facilitate the installation of the Bachittar Natak!! Waheguru Ji Save us all. I have had the benefit of reviewing the whole livestream video and to make matters worst the Academy spokesperson even went to the extent of describing in detail how the BN should be revered and placed in the Darbar in the presence of Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.

    There is a saying that if you want to understand another human being, watch that persons actions. Truly Academy has lived up to every word of this saying.

    Finally shame on those who are hell bent on going against the COMMAND of Guru Gobind Singh Ji “Sab Sikhan Ko Hukan Hare Guru Maniyo Granth” (Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji).

  5. If this has happened bringing DG into the Darbar of SGGS, then I would say that this is the end of the reverence to SGGS. By doing yhis act, now we have deceived our great Gurus. I can certainly say that this act is performed to please Personal Agenda. I can foresee that soon there would be another special Darbar to cater for the followers of DG in Malaysia. It’s clear that the doctrine would differ and so will be the method of delivery of the Divine knowledge the we Sikhs have been receiving till todate. We have Naamdharis, Nirankaris, Radhaswamis, Akalis, and now Dasam Granth Poojaris. Good Luck to this break and people involved in this mission. The outcome of this act will o ly become apparent in 10 years to come when it would have become irreversible.